Archive for the ‘Best Practices’ Category

7 Ways to Increase Readership of your Newsletters

Thursday, August 12th, 2010

The Newsletter remains a cornerstone of many organizations’ email marketing. Deservedly so – a newsletter is flexible enough to communicate anything important, and structured enough to be easy to write. It also carries an official connotation from the organization: subscribers who see “newsletter” anticipate that its contents are somewhere in the continuum between relevant and required reading.

For these reasons, we would all like our newsletters to be more widely read. Even if their open rates and clicks are already strong, the more people who read the organization’s official word, the easier it is to further the organization’s objectives. Here are seven ways to make this email staple work even harder:

1. Give it a name. Calling your newsletter “Newsletter” is certainly accurate, though it stops short of giving the subscription a personality. The name of the newsletter for the department of sanitation in my county is called “The Paperless Airplane.” If a newsletter about picking up trash and recycling can have a catchy moniker, so can yours.

2. Add a contextual subject line. Many newsletters are titled by date or issue with subject lines to match, such as “Association XYZ Newsletter: August 2010.” While it is true that this subject line convention relieves the author of the burden of decision-making, a subject line that telegraphs the newsletter content would likely lift open rates. Do a few issues of A/B testing with an option like “XYZ Newsletter 8/10: Annual Meeting Pics and Presentations.” Soon you will have a good sense of what types of content references in the subject line your newsletter audience finds most appealing.

3. Post your newsletter as a web version. Your newsletter subscribers (and others you would like to be your newsletter subscribers) also spend time on your website, so why not use the media there to promote a link to the web version of your newsletter? Pointing to the web version won’t require any additional layout of formatting work and allows you to still benefit from Real Magnet’s analytics. Promote the web version in a “What’s New” section on your homepage, on your blog, and through your social media channels as well to distribute your newsletter to the widest possible audience.

4. Post newsletter archives online. And now that you’re using the web version of your newsletter, why not create a simple page on your website that serves as an archive of your recent newsletters? Again, no additional publishing work for the newsletters themselves is necessary. All you need to do is include the links Real Magnet generates to the recent web versions you would like to include. Then in the newsletter itself, point your subscribers to your Newsletter Archive page so they can review previous newsletters whenever they like.

5. Add a new section. One of the advantages to newsletters is that they are easy to template. Each one can include the same categories of content, making them easy to write and predictable to your subscribers. But the downside of rigid templating is that it can fatigue over time and start to feel a little formulaic. Try interrupting your regularly scheduled newsletter with a fresh new section – one that is noticeably different from the rest of the newsletter so that it really stands out. Maybe it is a single industry-relevant data point conveyed in a brightly colored graphic. Or it is a comment or quotation from someone known within your industry. Maybe it is a photo from a recent industry event, identifying the subjects with a caption (people love to see pictures of each other and themselves). Many newsletters are all work. Think of this section as the whistle that goes along with it.

6. Launch a win-back program for the unengaged. You probably have many subscribers to your newsletter who have not opened it in the previous 6, 9 or even 12 issues. Continuing to send to them and hoping for an improvement is a scenario for disappointment. Instead, identify these subscribers through recpeient-level tracking and run a separate win-back campaign for them. The objective of the campaign is to target them separately with a message or offer that will re-engage them with the organization. If they read the message, click-through, interact with some content on the other side (such as a poll or a video or a photo gallery or a blog post), the connection between them and your organization will be rekindled, and they are more likely to see the next newsletter you send them as relevant to them. And when this happens, you’ve just earned yourself another newsletter reader.

7. Recruit more subscribers. We all know this, but we don’t always do everything we can to encourage more people to subscribe to our newsletters. Take an inventory of all the sources of your subscribers, then compare it to all the points of contact you have with people who should be your subscribers. If the lists don’t match up, you have just identified new places to add a mechanism for joining your list.

How (and Why) to Write your own Email Case Study

Thursday, August 5th, 2010

Mike May, Director of Insights

As an email marketer, I’m fond of case studies. I attend conferences to hear them, scour the trades to read them, and pick the brains of other email marketers to surreptitiously discover them. I feel pretty strongly that one of the best ways to get smart about email marketing and about how to use Real Magnet’s products is to learn how your contemporaries are doing it – within your industry and in others.

But the one way I know of to get even smarter about email marketing than reading case studies is to write them. The act of writing your own case study – about how and how effectively your organization uses email – brings clarity and candor to the practice and requires you to truthfully assess the discipline and strategy you bring to the practice. And the finished product – even if intended only for your internal colleagues’ eyes –  invites the constructive feedback of other stakeholders.

Why not try it? Follow these steps to create a case study of your own, and see if you don’t become your own best student in the process:

1. Define the scope of your case study. The narrower the better. As an email marketer you’d be less interested in a colleague presenting on “How we approach email marketing” than you would “A/B Testing for Open Rate Improvement” or “Mobile Subscription Channel Launch and Adoption.” Hidden in this step is the principal reason writing your own email case study is so valuable: in order to have a case study to write, you need to have initiatives within your email program worth chronicling. If the only case study topic you can come up with is “Lessons on Sending out a Lot of Emails and Hoping for the Best” then you’ve already learned something from this process that you might not pick up reading someone else’s case study.

2. Outline the success metrics. As you’re preparing to write your case study, include a list of all the metrics you decided previously to use in order to measure the success of your initiative. For example, if your case study is on “The Launch of a Niche Newsletter to a subset of our Subscriber Base,” your success metrics might include total subscribers by time, percent of house list who subscribers, percent of target niche who subscribes, as well as open-rate and click metrics from the niche newsletter compared to the primary. As above, it’s possible you might not have articulated the success metrics for your initiative at the outset of the initiative, so your case study work becomes a little retroactive. The act of writing the case study is a good reminder that these metrics are critical from the very beginning of a project, and should help you remember to define them proactively with your next case study worthy initiative.

3. Compile your data into tables and graphs. It’s useful to be able to say at a marketing meeting, “The open rate on our emails has been increasing.” But it’s much more insightful to show a table with the open rate by message over the past year. Better still, roll out a line graph charting the open rate from message to message so that it’s easier to isolate the changes and trace back their causes, and draw some conclusions about future trends as well. Visual representation of data does take some work, but is extremely powerful in communicating key findings and inviting productive feedback and follow-up questions. Inevitably, the marketer to glean the most from the graphs is the one who prepared them in the first place.

4. Reflect on what might have been. Now that you’ve compiled your data, made your charts and drawn your conclusions, step back and play a couple rounds of “what if?” Is there a conclusion you’d like to be able to draw but didn’t capture the necessary data in the process? Do ideas appear for how to improve the initiative itself next time based on the data and conclusions you’ve laid out? If you could start the whole thing all over again, what would you change? Include all this within your case study – in part to catalog some of the learning you’ve achieved merely by preparing the case study, and in part to set the course for the next email initiative or case study which will include these very improvements.

Tools for Mobile Email – Coming in September!

Wednesday, July 28th, 2010

“Already 64% of key decision makers use their smartphones to check and read their email.” — MarketingSherpa

As the market for mobile devices powers forward, more recipients are viewing your messages on smartphones, iPads, and other gadgets. In September, Real Magnet will release a tool set to help you market more effectively to this expanding group of mobile recipients. These tools for mobile email are comprised of three components:

Mobile Content Creation Tool

You’ll be able to create a mobile version of your message with new content editing tools. With a click, Real Magnet will auto-generate a web version of your message that is optimized for mobile rendering. You’ll have maximum flexibility to edit this mobile-web version according to your own requirements.

Mobile Indicators and Geo-Location Tracking

Real Magnet’s message tracking is expanding to include new metrics on how and where your messages are being viewed. This data can play a critical role in your targeting efforts. For each message, you’ll now see:

  • Open % – mobile vs. PC
  • % breakdown of Opens by mobile devices
  • % breakdown of Opens by browsers (PC and mobile)
  • % breakdown of Opens by Operating System
  • Opens by recipient location

On the main tracking page for each message, you’ll see the graphic below.  You can mouse over the pie charts to see percentages and drill down to get the details.

Mobile Tracking

Overview Technical and Geo-Location Display

Mobile Rendering Previews

Just like the email in-box you use on the web (Outlook, Yahoo!, Gmail, etc.), different smartphones will render your HTML messages differently. As part of this release, a rendering preview feature will be added that provides the actual display of your content in the most popular devices, such as iPhones, Blackberrys, Window mobile, and others), so you can avoid design mishaps BEFORE sending your message.

Preview of Blackberry

Preview of Blackberry

Preview of iPhone

Preview of iPhone

In the upcoming weeks, more information on the Tools for Mobile Email release will be available right here, so stay tuned!

The Day After: 24-hour Post-Email Analytics

Tuesday, July 13th, 2010

The upside to email marketing is that the performance data and analytics are so abundant that it’s possible to measure almost any aspect of your messages and campaigns. But the challenge inherent to that upside is that with so much available data, it’s often difficult to know where – or when – to start.

So let’s solve that right now. The “when” is 24 hours after you send each message. The “where” is in the Track module within MagnetMail. Here are 5 analytics in 5 minutes to make you a savvier email marketer with your very next message:

Log into your MagnetMail account and go to Track right up there at the top. Click on the header for the Date Sent column – that arranges your messages chronologically, with the most recent at the top. (MagnetMail will remember this setting and default to it next time.) Double-click yesterday’s message to open its analytics.

1. Take in the data and bars in the Message Sent Results. Look first at the rates for deliverability, open and click-through. They won’t tell you anything today, but do this after every message and you’ll start to see trends. It’s like weighing yourself in the morning. Today you have a single data point. Is this good news or not? The question is best answered by the direction you’re trending, not your current status. Start to learn those trends. See which way you’re headed.

2. Now look at the absolute numbers for Opens, Links and Unsubscribes. Think about what these numbers mean with respect to your objectives. For example, if you want 1000 people to attend your conference and you are emailing your full house list, are the 700 opens and 150 click-throughs encouraging results because they’re part of a larger campaign, or cause to start looking for ways to grow your house list? Rates and percentages are great because they normalize the data, but applying some real-world context to absolute numbers in your analytics is just as vital.

3. Next to the Bounced rate is a little green table. Click it to see how your bounces are categorized. If you don’t already know the different categories, familiarize yourself with what they mean by clicking on the link for each Bounced Type. MagnetMail automatically resends bounces multiple times in the hours following your message and once more overnight. But sometimes the problems that lead to Generic Soft bounces aren’t resolved immediately so resending these bounces the next day is a good idea. Uncheck all the Bounced Types except the Generic Soft. Then click Resend Bounces to try reaching this group with your message again. (I’ll address the other bounce types later, but it doesn’t hurt to look at the actual lists of your different bounced types now as well.)

4. Return to your Message Send Results. Next to the bar chart you’ve been looking at is a thumbnail image of your message. Below the thumbnail is a link to Click-view. Click it – it’s awesome. You’ll see where on the message your readers are clicking, giving you and idea of what impact content, language and even position within the message have on click-throughs. If you see strong clicks even well below the fold, for example, you’ll know that your entire message is being read. If they’re all concentrated at the top, consider shorter copy. Are there long copy blocks without any links? Could you add some to convert some of that attention into action? Do this with every email and you’ll see rapid improvements in your copywriting and layout skills.

5. Return again to the top level of your message’s analytics. Below Message Send Results is Domain Level Tracking. Click on Delivered to sort the domains in this list from lowest delivery rate to highest. It’s not uncommon for emailers – particularly B2B and associations – to have some domains with deliverability rates well below the message’s average. If you see some domains in this list with a Delivered percentage at 30 or more points lower than your Total Delivered percentage, it could signal a blacklist issue at that domain. If you are a B2B emailer you probably know people at that organization. Have them put you in touch with the organization’s email administrator, who can help you resolve the deliverability issues that are preventing your messages from reaching a large percentage of that domain’s audience.

These 5 steps are at the very top level of Real Magnet’s analytics capabilities. You can go much deeper into analytics than the top level of message tracking we’re looking at here. But if you spend just 5 minutes on these steps the day after you send each message, you’ll start to see the trends that can improve your emails almost immediately. Gain comfort with these and it won’t be long before you’re ready for deeper dives into tracking and reporting.

From ‘You’ve Got Mail’ To ‘Inbox Zero’

Wednesday, June 30th, 2010

Merlin Mann is the quirkily charismatic force behind 43folders.com, a popular blog about unlocking creativity and productivity. One of the concepts he floated a few years back is called “Inbox Zero” and is about developing a process to manage email as soon as it comes in, so that the weight of your inbox is no longer a burden. Now he’s writing a book on the topic, which means a publisher somewhere thinks “Inbox Zero” is an idea that is ready for prime time. Put another way, someone whose job it is to find and publish books that sell millions of copies thinks “Inbox Zero” fits the bill and will make the publishing company (and the publisher) piles of money. I’ve followed “Inbox Zero” for a while. You can too, on its website. I agree with the book’s publisher that it’s a potentially explosive idea, so my article for MediaPost this week is about how to prepare for an Inbox Zero world. You can read it in full below or over on the MediaPost site.

From ‘You’ve Got Mail’ To ‘Inbox Zero’
by Mike May
published on 6.30.10 in MediaPost’s Email Insider

In 1998, the Tom Hanks/Meg Ryan romantic comedy “You’ve Got Mail” was released. Buoyed by an infectious consumer enthusiasm over the freshness and marvel of instantaneous person-to-person electronic communication, the film grossed a quarter of a billion dollars at the box office. If you’re in the email industry, you don’t just remember the late ’90s; you pine for them. People (they were just “people” then, not consumers or subscribers or — gasp — segments) genuinely liked getting email.

Fast-forward to 2010. Merlin Mann, the productivity champion behind the popular 43folders.com blog, has a book called “Inbox Zero” due out this year. The book springs from some articles Mann originally wrote for 43folders.com, which he spun into a presentation he delivers at companies across the country. One of these was at Google, and the hour-long video of his talk has been viewed over 300,000 times.

“Inbox Zero” claims powerfully to be “about how to reclaim your email, your attention, and your life.” Says Mann, “Just remember that every email you read, re-read, and re-re-re-re-re-read as it sits in that big dumb pile is actually incurring mental debt on your behalf. The interest you pay on email you’re reluctant to deal with is compounded every day and, in all likelihood, it’s what’s led you to feeling like such a useless slacker today.” Like a good email marketer, Mann regards attention as the dearest of commodities. But his energy is channeled towards protecting that attention from intruding email, rather than capturing it: “Give each message as much attention as it needs and not one iota more. Remember the contextuality of triage: if you keep trying to care for dead and doomed patients, you’ll end up losing a lot of the ones who could have actually used your help.”

“Inbox Zero” teaches citizens of the Internet a process for managing inbound email so that it ultimately becomes less of a burden, and more of a communications channel. It’s a self-help book, which means it has the potential to be wildly successful. If a quarter of a billion dollars worth of movie audiences were enraptured by the thought of inbox romance in 1998, how large to you think the prospective audience for a book about help with email will be today? (Hint: it’s a number larger than your house file.)

If the book and the concept of  “Inbox Zero” do catch fire (I believe they will), the rules for email engagement will tighten down even further. The net result will be comparable to many of the other changes the industry has faced, from spam filters to engagement-based metrics. The gulf between successful, legitimate, disciplined, honorable emailers — and those who are, well, not — will continue to grow.

What does your organization need to do now to get on the right side of that chasm? Here are the attributes that I believe will distinguish the email haves from the have-nots in an Inbox Zero world:

Respect: Increasingly, people are going to be putting energy into developing and maintaining the processes to balance email with the rest of their lives. Email marketers should look at the soft drink companies for some guidance here. Faced with the movement towards weight management and healthier lifestyles, the soft drink companies tried first to make it even easier to get a soda, through aggressive promotions, partnerships with (and funding for) schools to get vending machines installed, and aggressive sponsorship and brand promotion. The smarter and more recent approach is to swim the current, not against it. Soft drink companies today have diversified by offering fruit juices, sports drinks and fortified water. Emailers need to take the long view toward harmonious coexistence within new inbox lifestyles. Respect the process your subscribers are trying to implement, instead of focusing all your energy toward trying to disrupt it.

Relevance: As the premium on attention increases, relevance and anticipation become the preferred currency. The best advice I can offer on that front is to point out that the best advice is already out there. Reread every article you’ve ever seen on relevance.

Brevity: There is a pat response in the direct marketing industry to the question about how much copy a marketing communication should contain: “It should be as long as you can still hold your audience’s attention.” After “Inbox Zero,” that’s bunk. It’s a very selfish mentality for marketers to believe they’re entitled to all the attention they can grab. It takes a short view and disrespects the consumer’s process. Attention is finite, so any excesses garnered by a single emailer come at the expense not just of competitors but of the reader’s ultimate objectives. “Inbox Zero” is very good news for disciplined emailers, so encouraging its adoption should supersede monopolizing inbox attention.

Humility: Mann points out that the reason email carries such psychic weight is because it is out of our control. We cannot choose who sends us email, how many we receive or — importantly — the expectations of the senders. The result is that the entire inbox feels urgent, and “getting through” the inbox quickly becomes a manic preoccupation. Successful emailers in an Inbox Zero world will cede control to consumers, giving them broader options for managing their subscriptions: preferences centers, “lite” subscriptions, subscribing through alternate channels such as RSS, mobile or even Twitter can and should be offered.

If “Inbox Zero” arrived today, which side of the gulf would your company be on? If you regard it as an opportunity, you’re likely already in position. But if you see it as a threat, you’ve got some hard work in front of you.

All of the Above: 5 New Uses for Online Surveys

Friday, June 25th, 2010

I note with some irony that I have never come across an online survey about the popularity of online surveys. But anecdotally I can certainly confirm that they’re past the gaining traction stage and have become an essential business tool for many companies. And why not? They are very easy to administer, provide instantaneous feedback, and can be employed across many different business application, from customer satisfaction to marketing intelligence to sales support.

Many Real Magnet clients are using surveys for these very purposes. Trade associations commonly send out annual or even quarterly member satisfaction surveys; publishers measure audience interests in advance of launching new publications or issuing free trial subscriptions; and surveys to measure feedback after conferences or webinars are nearly de rigueur at this point.

But there are some lesser-known, equally profitable uses of online surveys that businesses should consider, particularly if you’re already using Real Magnet for email. Here’s a start:

1. Voting and Elections. Board of Directors elections are an annual occurrence for trade associations, and Real Magnet’s Surveys Module is a perfect platform for them. Because it integrates seamlessly with Real Magnet, re-sending the ballot-survey to members who have not yet voted is easy. An example from a different industry is a major publisher, who uses online voting of magazine cover choices to its audience. A panel of its readers pick which cover they prefer and that’s what the magazine runs with. Voting can also be rolled out in more casual environments, such as a “photo of the year” or other applications which are more public expressions of preference and popularity than a controlled data-collection environment. For these informal uses, you can elect to publish the results of some questions in real-time, so respondents can see if their choice is winning.

2. Research. The challenge with most industry research is that most companies are happy to receive it and study the benchmarks, but are far less willing to actually contribute the data necessary to compile the research. This makes survey response rates extremely pivotal in research quality. And nobody understands response rates like email marketers. So why not treat your surveys in the same way you do your email campaigns? By building your research surveys through Real Magnet, you can track analytics in much the same way as you currently evaluate your email, and through the same familiar interface. You’ll know who has responded and who hasn’t, when responses come through, and also be able to drill down into the email response history of your research targets, to see if their email response history sheds some light on their reactions to surveys. If research is important to your organization – let alone your industry – apply the same rigor in conducting and analyzing the process as you do in your mission-critical email marketing.

3. Customer Engagement. Ultimately, surveys are a conversation. You ask questions; your customers or members respond. Getting them to leave comments on your blog or to retweet your news requires some initiative on their part, so it happens infrequently. But filling out a survey can be little more than following a link and clicking on some radio buttons or check boxes. To respondents, it feels a lot more like surfing than it does participating or actively voicing an opinion. But it breaks the seal, and does compel your audience to interact with you on some level. I like to include surveys as part of email winback campaigns, particularly very short ones that don’t include any open-ended questions or ask for personal information. If you have email subscribers who haven’t opened or clicked anything in a while, consider sending them a very brief survey asking for their opinion on a topic you believe is highly important to them. If it’s interesting and simple, you stand the greatest chance to get them to respond, which is the first step in winning them back and re-engaging them.

4. Customer Intelligence and Segmentation. The data most marketers examine from surveys are the answers that respondents provide. But if you think about your surveys as a measure of customer engagement (see #3), then who is responding is as telling as what they are saying. Wouldn’t it be valuable to know what 10% of your audience is the most connected to your organization? Look no further than the list of people who responded to your last online survey. They’ve taken action to provide you with feedback, which required effort on their part. Presumably the effort is worthwhile to them because they intend to continue their relationship with you. Regardless of what they say in the survey, the fact that they said anything is a powerful piece of customer intelligence. If you’ve conducted this survey through Real Magnet, it’s easy to move these respondents into their own group, and target them later with other high-engagement offers, such as Share-With-Your-Network (SWYN) campaigns, or special early registration offers for conferences and webinars.

5. Registrations and Sign-ups. At its core, our Surveys Module is a very robust forms platform that ports all collected information into a database Real Magnet clients are already familiar with. Click around your website and look at every other place you use forms – in particular those that collect data that doesn’t go into a central database, but instead drops it all into an email to someone (probably you) who has to manually input it into a spreadsheet. Would it make your life easier if some of those dropped data directly into the same database you use to generate email? For example, do you use a form to collect registration data for informal events like cocktail receptions? How do your members apply to be a part of committees? If you haven’t yet opened registration for your big conference, do you use a form to collect email addresses from people who want to be notified when they can sign up? All of this can be done with the Real Magnet Surveys Module, and the data you collect goes straight into the database you already use for email.

What would you like online surveys to help you with? Building stronger relationships with customers, collecting actionable insight, reducing your workload, or all of the above?

10 Email Evolutions, and how to Respond to Them (Part 2 of 2)

Thursday, June 10th, 2010

mmay150x150
Previously I wrote on the first 5 Email Evolutions (and how to respond to them). Below are #6 – #10.

6. Subscribers are using inbox filters. Almost every major ISP (Hotmail, Yahoo!, Gmail) and client-side email applications (Outlook, Mac Mail, Thunderbird, Eudora) offers inbox filtering, and there are no shortage of tutorials and tips on how to set them up to manage inbound email. And by “manage” most tutorials mean something between “delay reading” to “mark for deletion.” The objective of filters for most subscribers is to group messages that require a similar mindset to approach. Some might set up a filter for all email from travel sites and airlines, so they have a starting point for planning a trip or looking for a promotion. Others might group together all messages that include a certain company name. There is no way of knowing if it benefits your organization to be included in a subscriber’s filter or not, since you’re not sure if the purpose of a filter is “ignore this” or “save this for later” or “ooh – this is hot hot hot!” But you might market differently if you knew your messages were being filtered out, and how. Survey your subscribers to see if and how they’re using filters, and consider what course of action makes the most sense. It may be that including a few choice keywords in your emails will get your messages into preferred filters, or changing your sender address might keep some emails out of less desirable filters. You might also conclude that teaching some subscribers how to set up a filter expressly for your company’s messages is worthwhile. Even if your messages aren’t always visible in the preview pane, your brand is front and center every time your subscriber checks mail.

7. Your brand’s relationship with your subscriber may have changed. You can think of half a dozen reasons why this may have happened: your subscriber may have changed jobs, might have already purchased the product you offer, might be in a different life stage and not currently in market for your company’s services, or might no longer do business with you or be a member of your organization. As your subscribers’ relationships with you change, so does their need for communications from you, and the perceived relevance of those communications. It is difficult to pinpoint exactly when it is happening or to whom, so the best way to manage evolving relationships is to let subscribers do it themselves. More often than not, a subscriber who is less engaged than before but still connected to your organization wants something in between “send me everything” and “unsubscribe.” They want to stay in touch, but maybe don’t want a steady drumbeat from you. Consider a “lite” subscription of your emails, and offer it to subscribers who have been with you for a while, but whose engagement has trailed off. Better to keep them in the fold than for them to reach a point of saturation and ultimately unsubscribe, even if it means finding their inbox only half or even a quarter of the time.

8. There is simply more email for your subscribers to get through. This is a little different from the Clutter I wrote about in #4. Clutter is a lot of stuff subscribers don’t want but still get. Here I’m talking about the increase in the amount of relevant communication that takes place through email. People use email more than they used to. We used it to keep in touch with our customers, our suppliers, our spouses, our parents, our college friends, our lawnmowing service and our kids’ teachers. We’re in it all the time, and there is a pressing need to “get through it.” Your objective is for your messages to be part of the group that has to be “gotten through” and not the “clutter” that subscribers work around. To get there, empathize with your subscribers. Focus less on everything you want to tell them, and more on how much they have time to read. Succinct, clear, relevant messages are more important than ever. Think about the state of your own inbox before you push a message into someone else’s.

9. Subscribers are always online. Finally – an evolution that actually creates an opportunity for email marketers, instead of another challenge. All of a sudden, sending messages in the evening, early morning and even on weekends begins to make sense. Your subscribers are online at all hours, so throw out your “best practices” of when to send and see if you can find new hot spots for capturing their attention.

10. Subscribers expect to communicate 2-ways. We have social media to thank for this evolution. We talk to our customers and expect them to listen. Now they talk to us and expect us to listen. That means that it’s time to lose the “do not reply” address and make it easy for your subscribers to turn your messages into a conversation. Isn’t that the whole point after all?

Keeping pace with all these changes may seem like a lost cause. But the reality is that you don’t have to keep pace to still come out ahead. Let me explain by way of anecdote:

A man is meeting his buddy at the trailhead in the woods, where the two of them plan to set out on a day long hike. His buddy looks down at the man’s feet and says, “Why are you wearing running shoes? We’re going for a hike in the woods.”

The man replies, “because there are bears in these woods.”

“Bears?!” his friend exclaims. “But you can’t outrun a bear. They can go like 30 miles per hour.”

The man looks down at his buddy’s feet, shod in heavy, rugged hiking boots. “Oh, it’s not the bear I have to outrun…”

You’re not going to outrun your subscribers. They’re too nimble and unpredictable. But if you’re resourceful, responsive and purposeful you’ll surely outpace your competitors, leaving you to hike on another day.

10 Email Evolutions, and how to Respond to Them (Part 1 of 2)

Wednesday, June 9th, 2010

mmay150x150
I began my career in email marketing in 1997. Email was novel and exciting, and consumers were genuinely interested to receive most messages. Many were even disappointed to open their inboxes and find them empty. If you weren’t lucky enough to ply your email trade back then, imagine what it would have been like for every one of your messages to be anticipated, and each of your subscribers to be grateful to hear from you.

Here are 10 of the more recent evolutions of email, along with tips for how we as email marketers should respond to them. How many are you already employing? How many can you implement quickly and see a lift right away?

1. Email addresses have matured. Hotmail launched in 1996. Yahoo! Mail was born in 1997. Some AOL addresses have been in use even longer. Some of  your subscribers addresses are 10 years old or older. Even gmail, the relative newcomer in the free inbox market, has been around since 2004. The longer your subscribers have had an email address, the more subscription lists their address appears on. That means more mature address are likely to receive more email. Conversely, older addresses may no longer be the preferred address and inboxes languish days, weeks, even months between openings. Either way, older email address are susceptible to lower open rates. Pay attention to your lag metrics and open rates for subscribers with these ISPs to see if a campaign asking for a fresher address makes sense. You want your messages to land in the most-favored inbox, not the one nearing retirement.

2. Image loading is often disabled. Some studies have found that as many as 50% of email messages reach inboxes with their image loading disabled. That means that these subscribers only see the text, and miss any promotional copy or offer that is part of a graphic in your email. If your messages are graphics heavy, make sure that your message appears in the copy as well. It may seem redundant to the subscribers who see both the images and the copy, but at least you’ll ensure that everyone who opens clearly reads your call to action.

3. More messages are read on mobile devices. Some smart phones will render your messages pretty well, making them as readable on a mobile device as they are on a computer. But that isn’t always the case, so make sure your messages are ready for reading even when picked up on the go. Keep an eye on your “view the web version” links: often mobile users unable to read messages on their phone will follow this link and use their phone’s browser instead. If you find many of your subscribers are viewing via mobile, maybe it’s time also to add SMS messaging.

4. Inboxes are more cluttered. The good news is that email has lost none of its relevance as a critical communications channel. The bad news is that every single company knows this, and works very hard to make sure their messages are in your subscribers’ inboxes as well. What to do? Augment your use of email with other channels of customer contact, like social media, direct mail, SMS, fax and advertising. The more relevant your brand is to your subscribers outside of the inbox, the more likely your emails will rise above the din in the inbox.

5. That darn Facebook made privacy concerns a headline again. Over the past five years, the biggest change I’ve seen in consumer behavior online is the rise in expectations of consumer control. More than ever, your subscribers want to govern what they consume and when they consume it, whether it’s TV on-demand or through a DVR, or limiting access to their inbox. I’m convinced that resistance to this movement is futile. Now is the time to cede control to your subscribers through a preferences center. Let them choose which messages to receive, and which to opt-out from. It may mean tweaking your content strategy a bit so that you don’t have an all-or-nothing approach, but it will be well worth the effort. The size of your list is no longer a meaningful metric. Allowing your subscribers to self-segment may mean fewer recipients for each messages, but should yield a greater overall ROI to your email program.

Evolutions 6-10 are coming up soon in Part 2.

Three Ways to Optimize Email (that aren’t actually about email)

Tuesday, June 1st, 2010

I’ve written before about optimizing email. In fact, that’s almost all I write about here – ways to pump up your results through better subject lines, more targeted content strategies, list management, A/B testing and other tactics. Many of the features and reports you need to improve your email results are already built into the Real Magnet application.

Some are not, though I maintain that it’s not our fault. There are ways of improving your email program that have nothing to do with the act of composing and distributing email itself, but rely instead on activities that take place before and after the email process. Let’s call it extra-email optimization, or optimization of email that takes place outside of email. When we focus on our email metrics, it’s easy to get a little bit myopic. When we look at click-through rate, for example, we aren’t so concerned with how many people click through our messages as we are how many are then in a position to register for our conference, or who then generate page views and ad impressions on our website. Your emails are not by themselves an initative; they’re a tool for driving a larger company objective.

Your email, then, better achieves your organization’s objectives if:

- More people subscribe to it
- Your subscribers are more inclined to open and act on your emails
- If they complete whatever action the click-through encourages them to take

None of this happens within the email itself. But the success of your emails can be heavily influenced by optimizing each of these steps with your email program in mind. Here’s how:

More subscribers: Are you doing everything you can to grow your list, by allowing people to opt in when registering for your conference, downloading white papers on your site or making online purchases? Is it easy to join your list in the “Contact Us” and/or “About Us” section of your website? Have you used your social channels to promote your newsletter and other email subscriptions? What about your physical presence – do you collect email addresses at storefronts, trade shows and other places where you exist in the real world? Be resourceful and vigilant in your recruitment efforts. Every minute of resources you put into composing and distributing your emails is amplified by each additional subscriber you have.

Greater inclination to open and act on messages: This isn’t about sending more interesting or targeted messages. Rather, it’s about anticipation. Your subscribers need to expect and even look forward to your messages. With the rise in email volume over the past few years, anticipation has become one of the most challenging elements of email marketing. Certainly improved targeting of messages and list hygiene helps, but I’m a strong believer that your organization’s relationship with your subscribers outside of the inbox can yield the greatest lift. I’ve written about email in the marketing mix previously, and anticipation is where it pays off in spades. The more you are in your subscribers’ lives – via social channels or on the phone or in person or via direct mail – the more relevant your brand becomes. Relevancy begets anticipation. Your email program will work better if you supplement it with other points of customer contact.

Post-click-through action: Fire up your website analytic engine. It’s time to take a look at your landing pages, and how well they’re performing. You’re already testing different elements of your email to see what works better – this subject line, that layout, those links. Do you do the same thing with what happens on the other side of the click-through? Do you know, for example, if your conference marketing emails drive more registrations by driving your email subscribers to the conference main page, the agenda, or the registration page? Do you see deeper engagement if you drop your subscribers off on your homepage, or deliver them deeper into your website? Independent of your email, have you put resources into merchandising your content effectively, usability testing, or shopping cart / checkout optimization? Online retailers live and breathe for these tactics, and other business can learn a lot from their best practices. Think about it: if you’re trying to drive a webinar registration or encourage someone to sign up for your premium online content or services, you’re in the e-commerce business too. And even if you’re not competing with Amazon.com, your customers have had their expectations on usability and checkout set there.

Next time you see a meeting invite for a project at your company that iss outside of the scope of email marketing, think about it in this new context. Giving email a seat in that conference room could mean more subscribers, greater anticipation, and improved results.

Legislative Update: Is the FTC Finished with E-mail?

Friday, May 21st, 2010

I sat in on an FTC legislative update webinar presented by The E-mail Experience Council Wednesday afternoon, and thought it might be useful to run down some of the high points for the Real Magnet blog.

Lois Greisman of the FTC started the webinar by asserting that CAN SPAM “leveled the playing field” by providing a road map for legitimate marketers to follow in terms best practices, and a way to distinguish good actors from the bad. I’m not sure I agree with her on that last point; I receive a daily bucket load of unsolicited bulk e-mail that complies with CAN SPAM, and I have trouble discerning the good actors among them.

She noted that the law has been a useful tool for going after certain types of spammers. As an example, she points to the US$2.9-million judgment against ValueClick, who last spring were found to have used brazenly deceptive subject lines in their e-mail (remember the “click here for a free iPod” guys?), among other sins.

Greisman stated flat out that the FTC is uninterested in pursuing broader e-mail specific protections, noting that Congress spoke quite clearly in the passage of the law, and had carefully considered but eventually discarded stiffer requirements. The FTC seems to be signaling that CAN SPAM, with all its flaws, will remain the law of the land as written (and subsequently clarified in the rules update of May 2008), and that we should not expect additional e-mail marketing specific requirements anytime soon.

Legislators are, however, considering an expansion of FTC rule-making authority and enforcement powers that has the Direct Marketing Association a bit nervous. In some cases, it would allow the FTC to impose immediate civil penalties on fraudsters, and give them the opportunity to “go down the food chain” after organizations that aided and abetted the fraud.

For details on these and other topics addressed in the webinar, have a look at my twitter time line for my live narrative of the hour-long session. You’re very welcome to follow me there.  You may also follow Real Magnet’s twitter here.

Andrew Barrett is Sr. Director, ISP Relations & Deliverability at Real Magnet.